The Phantom of the Opera, Her Majesty’s Theatre, London review ✭✭✭✭✭

Last Updated on 17 August 2021 by Showcall Editorial Team

Mark Ludmon reviews Andrew Lloyd Webber’s The Phantom of the Opera on its return to Her Majesty’s Theatre in London with Killian Donnelly and Lucy St Louis

Phantom of the Opera London
Killian Donnelly and Lucy St Louis in The Phantom of the Opera at Her Majesty’s Theatre. Photo: Johan Persson

The Phantom of the Opera
Her Majesty’s Theatre, London

After 35 years, The Phantom of the Opera continues to pull in audiences at Her Majesty’s Theatre. After a Covid-19 hiatus, it is back at its original home albeit with a few changes. The orchestra has been halved to 14 and the set has been tweaked, with director Seth Sklar-Heyn building on the original direction by Harold Prince. Long-time fans have been sceptical but to an ordinary theatre-goer like myself, the show remains a gripping and exciting experience, full of spectacle and stirring tunes.

Lucy St Louis is the latest actor to play the part of Christine, a soprano who has been coached by a ghostly figure to become the star of the Paris opera house in the late 19th century. With a beautiful flawless voice, St Louis gives a mesmerising performance that establishes her as a new West End star. She is joined by an already established West End star, Killian Donnelly, who brings pathos and complexity to the role of the masked Phantom who terrorises the opera house in his obsession with Christine.

Phantom Opera London
Masquerade in The Phantom of the Opera in London. Photo: Johan Persson

Rhys Whitfield is excellent as Christine’s childhood sweetheart, Raoul, part of a faultless cast including Francesca Ellis as Madame Giry, Ellie Young as her daughter Meg, Saori Oda as preening prima donna Carlotta and Matt Harrop and Adam Linstead as theatre owners, Monsieurs Firmin and André.

The stunning set design by Maria Björnson remains impressive, retaining wow factors such as the large shimmering chandelier. Andrew Bridge’s lighting design adds to the gothic excitement, from romantic engagements on the top of the opera house to perilous chases through its underground caverns. It is still one of Andrew Lloyd Webber’s best scores, with lyrics by Charles Hart and Richard Stilgoe, and, while some of the richness of the orchestrations may have been lost through shrinking the band, the music is as magnificent as ever, with compelling melodies that continue to haunt you long afterwards.

Booking to 13 February 2022.


Phantom Opera London
Lucy St Louis and Killian Donnelly in The Phantom of the Opera in London
About Mark Ludmon 318 Articles
Mark Ludmon has been a journalist for over 20 years, specialising in theatre, hospitality and drinks after starting in regional daily newspapers. He has an MA in early modern literature and history, focusing on Elizabethan and Jacobean drama, and a theatre studies MA from Royal Central School of Speech & Drama. He is a former panellist for the Olivier Awards. He tweets at @MarkLudmon.